The screen test / gutter guards examined by the people who fit them Keys Roofing, St. Louis
Gutter Guards STLThe screen test Call (314) 220-2333

Examination no. 09 / the transaction

How to Read a Gutter Guard Sales Pitch

Gutter guards are sold at kitchen tables by people who are good at it. Knowing the moves in advance is not cynicism, it is preparation, and it works just as well on an honest quote.

Why this category is sold this way

A gutter guard is an unusual product. It costs enough to be a considered purchase, but not enough to make most people get three quotes the way they would for a roof. It is fitted somewhere the owner cannot easily inspect. Its performance is hard to judge for at least a full year. And the failure, when it comes, is gradual and easy to blame on the weather.

Those four facts together are why the category attracts hard selling. It is not that everybody in it is dishonest. It is that the product is structurally difficult for a buyer to verify, and a market like that rewards confident claims.

The five moves you will probably meet

The absolute promiseNever clean your gutters again. It is the founding claim of the category and it is not true of any product at any price. A firm that opens with it has told you what kind of conversation this is going to be, which is genuinely useful information.
The price that expires todayA discount available only while the representative is standing in your kitchen. Gutter guards are not perishable. A price that is real on Tuesday is real on Friday, and any structure designed to stop you thinking overnight exists for that purpose.
The fear pivotThe conversation moves from gutters to foundations, mould and basements. All of those are real consequences of water in the wrong place, and none of them is an argument for this product over simply keeping the gutter clear.
The paperwork flourishA thick document, a lifetime guarantee, a laminated card. Read what the remedy actually is. A promise to supply a replacement part is a very different thing from a promise to come out, get on a ladder and put it right at no charge.
The demonstrationWater poured from a jug over a sample of guard on the tailgate. It always works. A jug is not a cloudburst off a steep plane, and a handful of dry leaves is not a wet catkin mat in April. The demonstration is a fair illustration of the principle and no evidence at all about your house.

What you will be told

We are in your neighbourhood this week, so the crew is already local and I can hold this number for you.

What happens on the roof

Sometimes literally true and harmless. It is also the oldest structure in home improvement selling, and its function is to convert a considered purchase into a same day decision.

The test is simple and it costs nothing. Say you will decide on Friday. A firm that wants the work will still want it on Friday. A price that evaporates overnight was not a price, it was a technique.

Everything on this desk survives being read on Friday. That is roughly the standard to hold a quote to.

Eight questions that get real answers

  • How old is my roof, and how does that change your recommendation? If the answer is that it does not change it, the person quoting is not thinking about granules and has not read anything like this.
  • How is the guard fastened, exactly? To the gutter, under the shingles, or resting on the lip. There are only three answers and they predict how it survives winter.
  • If it goes under the shingles, how far up? A back edge pushed too far under can hold the course above open. This is the fault that turns a gutter product into a roof problem.
  • What is the maintenance interval, in plain words? Be suspicious of none. Every filter has one. A firm that gives you a real interval is telling you they expect to be around to service it.
  • When it does block, who comes, how fast, and is that visit charged? This is the single most useful question in the list and the one that most often changes the atmosphere in the room.
  • Is the guarantee transferable, and what is the remedy? Parts, or labour, or both. Read the remedy clause rather than the headline.
  • What did you find when you looked at the gutter itself? Size, fall, hangers, outlets. If nobody has mentioned any of those, you are being sold a product rather than a solution. See what is underneath.
  • Can I see one you fitted three or more years ago? Anybody can show you a guard fitted last month. The interesting one is the one that has been through three springs.

One thing no roofing contractor in Missouri may offer you

If a storm is part of this conversation, be aware that under RSMo 407.725 a roofing contractor may not represent or negotiate on a homeowner's behalf on an insurance claim, and may not advertise to pay, rebate or absorb any part of a deductible. Those are not customs, they are statutory prohibitions, and a firm offering either is telling you something about how it operates. A contractor can properly document a roof in writing and with photographs, and can meet an adjuster on site as the contractor. The claim itself remains between the homeowner and the insurer.

If a quote survives all eight questions, it is probably a good quote, and this desk has done its job either way. The other half of the preparation is knowing whether you need a guard at all: the worth it page.

Keep going

Read nextWhen a guard is worth the moneyRelatedLiving with guards afterwards

Second opinion

Send us the quote before you sign it

A gutter guard quote is short enough to read over the phone. What is being fitted, how it is fastened, what happens when it clogs and who pays for that visit. Those four answers tell you most of what you need.

Keys Roofing fits guards and is happy to say when a competing proposal is sound. A second opinion that agrees with the first one is still worth having.

(314) 220-2333

Straight to the Keys office. Roofing, gutters and downspouts across greater St. Louis. No siding, no windows, no commercial work.

A name and a number is enough. Someone from Keys will call you back.